If you've read this blog for a while, you know I'm interested in the major trend for adopting families to request girls. It's not really a trend even, it's like... a MOVEMENT or something. Way more than 50% of adopting families want girls. I've written about this before-- here I talked about my own realization that I was just like everyone else, feeling like we should have a girl. (An Asian girl, no less.)
Families who have sons want a girl to change things up. Families who have daughters want a girl so that the new child will fit in with her sisters. Families with no children yet picture themselves raising a girl.
Statistically, there should be just as many families who have only daughters asking for a son because they want the experience of raising a boy. There should be families who have only sons wanting another boy just because they're good at raising boys and they want the new child to fit in with his brothers. But... that's not what's happening, at least not often enough to make things even close to statistically even. Is it? Am I wrong about this?
I know lots of families who have specifically requested to adopt a girl, have been referred a girl by chance, or in one way or another ended up with lovely families which include daughters either by design or by chance. In no particular individual case does this bother me.
What does bother me is that adoptive parents (not you, just adoptive parents as a group) don't really examine this too much. We feel entitled to make the decision. And when potential adoptive parents feel entitled you cannot discuss with us that we may not be entitled because, damn it, yes we are and what are you trying to say about us anyway?
I'd like to see parents consider the possibility of some undiscovered racism or sexism in the automatic draw to adopt a girl. (Again, not you, just all of us, okay?) It's important to carefully consider the factors that lead us to these decisions, whatever the final decision turns out to be. How can that be a bad thing?
I don't know why I keep thinking about this every once in a while. It's odd that this particular issue keeps pestering me. I really believe that every family is different, family-building is complex and it's ridiculous to say to one family "You made the right decision" and to another "You made the wrong decision." We adoptive families need to be more supportive of each other, not less. So why rock the boat over gender selection?
I'm not trying to guilt families who have requested to adopt girls. It's not that people shouldn't adopt girls or shouldn't specifically want girls. Personally, there have been times when I've definitely wanted a daughter and wondered what we would do if we adopted again and if we could specify gender.
Maybe it's because it surprised me when I discovered that my initial assumptions about the race and gender of my yet-to-be adopted children probably were affected by some racism and sexism. I can hardly stand to think of not having my boys, and I'd hate for anyone else to miss out on adopting a son if it's an option for their family.
And honestly, yeah, occasionally I'm a bit... ruffled, maybe... about it at times. I happen to think my boys are pretty great. Sometimes I feel like MY family and MY decisions and MY SONS are being rejected. Like the whole world of adoptive parents would look at my kids and think, "Well, those boys are okay. For you. Myself, I wouldn't want them. I'm waiting for a girl."
Yes, I realize this is my own problem and I'm working on it. But do you understand just a tiny bit, even if you think I'm too dramatic and projecting and mean?
(As an aside, I'm interested to see if the changes in international adoption with the Hague convention and the slow down of adoptions from China and Guatemala in particular will impact the patterns of gender selection by potential adoptive parents.)
(I also realized while writing this post that the times I've talked about gender and adoption and building a family... Those posts were written two or even three years ago. Wow... Time flies. So here are links to a few posts with related topics, just in case you haven't been a devoted reader for three entire years:
Adopting Boys, thinking about reasons that PAPs tend to choose girls.
#3, debating with myself over whether or not I could specify gender in a potential future adoption, and then deciding that I didn't need to think about it.)