One of the pastors at our church said something during a sermon that was really offensive. I can't really vent about it anywhere else, so I'm going to write about it here.
The pastor was talking about freedom in Christ (I think) and used slavery and the Emancipation Proclamation in an illustration. He said that once the Emacipation Proclamation was signed, the slaves were free! They no longer had to serve their old masters! Whoo-hoo, freedom!
Beloved and I both exclaimed in protest (not yelling or anything, but said out loud something like "No, they could not just walk away!"), and looked around to see if other people were hearing what we were hearing. Well, apparently not.
I know most people who read this blog already understand this, but let me lay out why the illustration is offensive.
Least Offensive Interpretation: The comparison shows a lack of understanding of the consequences of slavery, the whole civil rights movement, and current race relations in the US. In addition, it shows a lack of understanding about how the Emancipation Proclamation actually worked and what it really stated.
Someone who thinks (or even implies for the sake of an illustration) that slaves could have just walked away is also probably someone who would say, "Well, slavery was a long time ago. We're all color blind now. Why make such a big deal about race stuff?"
Highly Offensive Interpretation: If the slaves could have just walked away after the Emancipation Proclamation and they didn't... They must have been stupid.
Interpretation Offensive in the Extreme: The slaves could have walked away, having been legally freed and all, but they didn't. They must have liked being slaves and could not manage without someone else thinking for them. Besides being stupid, they enjoyed and deserved enslavement, so slavery was not that big a deal anyway.
----------------------------------------------
The idea of the illustration was that Christ has given us freedom, but we don't recognize and claim that freedom. So I think the pastor was "only" Highly Offensive rather than Offensive in the Extreme. What do you think?
----------------------------------------------
We've been attending this church very regularly for the last three years. We love our small group. We like that it's a large congregation. (Large churches seems to have the resources for lots of interesting programs. But we're both introverts, and we like being able to participate where we want to and fade into the background the rest of the time.)
In the backs of our minds we always knew we wouldn't stay in this church body forever. We've noticed paternalistic attitudes when people in the church talk about serving other people. Kind of a racist or classist vibe here and there. Just weird stuff that we couldn't really put a finger on but that bugged us a bit anyway. But looking for a new church is time consuming and a lot of work, and we like so many other things about the church, so we put it off.
People who are easily offended and leave churches in a huff always seem self-absorbed and divisive to me. We did not and will not fuss, pout, and look for attention because we were offended. That's not it at all. It's just that the church rather suddenly stopped feeling like a home or a haven for us. Now we both feel cautious and a little sad.
I guess we should start looking... I know it's not possible to avoid all racism by changing churches, but we need to find some place that is at least trying a lot harder.